Old Garp vs Big Mom

Rules & Location

Round 1: H2H only. No help from her homies.

Round 2: Big Mom has her homies.

Location: Egghead Island

No prep time.

Win via K.O. or Death.

Both are in character.

Who wins?

If Garp and Roger were the only ones who took down the Rock Pirates, id say Garp wins over Big Mom.

BUMP

Big Mom both rounds

Garp whoops mid mom both rounds

Garp wins, Mom is no longer a spring chicken herself.

Big Mom has better feats at this point.

Garp beats tf outta her

Big mom old to she like 70 so I’d go Garp

They're both around the same age, and Garp has multiple statements and direct scaling putting him above her at their best. No reason to believe he's weaker than her now

I dont believe BM is her prime anymore. Garp wins

Big Mom wins high dif we haven't seen Garp do anything that Big Mom cant replicate, and we have Garp straight up saying hes lost a step we never get any such statement from Big Mom.

Big Mom is 68. Garp is 10 years her elder at 78.

Other than the fact that he has mentioned that he was weaker than he used to be on several occasions?

Garp has literally shown nothing that would put him over Big Mom

@cbarlion: what shows exactly BM to be superior?

Prime garp was yonko level, old garp is not.

Big Mom wins high difficulty.

Notis are out again I see.....

Garp's Galaxy impact barely leveled the town area that they were in and it seems as if he did not knock out any of the fodder that were there. He then blitzed and threw Aokiji into the ground but we do know what damage that would have down to Aokiji as yet.

Big Mom on the otherhand fodderized Marco, One shotted Page One and Ulti and K.Oed Kidd. Her basic elbaf spears are also visually way more impressive that anything Old Garp has down on panel so far.

@wushu59:

They both still old tbh….

@enemybird: How much weaker that is and how that compares to her is debatable, especially with his more current showings.

Big mom, garp is out of his prime.

@godlike_warrior: do you believe current garp "shit stomps" Kidd/Law 2v1?

No

He Stomps Law BUT finger flick Kidd

Bump

Garp mid diffs

Big Mom still wins

Garp Blue Hole’s the bitch to the ocean GG

BM still wins, there's not even enough to say Old Garp would beat Aokiji.

Garp was beating the shit out of Aokoji until he got screwed over. Based off his performance, he would definitely do better than Kidd and Law.

Hero!

garp was look meh and clearly not in yonko level in old age.

he would lose.

Garp win

Maybe round 1 Garp. I don't think the fist is losing in h2h to big mom, she hasn't shown the greatest AP or DC without her homies, but it's extreme dif, her durability makes it almost a battle of attrition. However, big mom isn't a yonkou because of h2h, she's a yonkou because of her homies, hax, and durability, she should take rd 2 mid dif

Garp, BM has better dura though

Garp Stomps