Spider-Man (MCU) vs Starlight (Amazon)

VS

In character.

Random encounter.

At night in Times Square.

Round 1: H2H only. No light, no web-shooters.

Round 2: All out fight.

Who wins?

Spidey with low to mid difficulty

Basically A-Train vs Starlight but without cardiac arrest

Starlight is tougher than Peter but peter has better strength feats and other stats. He should win both rounds with some difficulty...

Spidey can beat top tiers of The Boys verse, like Homelander, Maeve and Soldier Boy. Let alone this fodder.

@johndeyvido: is she even tougher than him? Other than taking bullets (which Peter’s also done with his suit) I really can’t think of anything that he couldn’t replicate.

Peter wins both rounds

Changing my answer to definitively Peter with low difficulty. Too quick and too strong

@a_fine_edition:

She is tougher...she tanked 50cal bullets and Peter was injured from a smaller calibre even though his suit cushioned the effects..

Frenchie needed a surgical saw with diamond tips to breach her skin and Black Noir was using her body to bust through multiple reinforced concrete pillars and she took that with little problem...

She's not quick nor strong enough to compete with Peter...

Starlight lights him up

Spidey stomps

Starlight might be more resilient than Spidey - at the very least, her skin is much tougher - but...that's about it. Her blasts don't really pack all that much of a punch compared to say, a pumpkin bomb, and her physical strength doesn't compare in the slightest.

She strained just to lift the back-end of a car - that's like, <1 ton. The first thing we see Spider-Man do with his powers is catch 3000 pounds moving at 40 miles an hour. That's not even mentioning things like holding the air bridge, and we haven't even gone past his debut in Civil War.

Spidey's also just far more agile and manoeuvrable as a whole, especially with his web-slinging shenanigans, and the spider-sense helps avoid projectile/ranged attacks quite well.

I can't really see this ending in anything other than a Spider-Man win.

I don’t even think blinding Peter with her blasts will help here, considering he did that entire NWH hallway sequence with his eyes shut relying entirely on his Spider Sense. It might disorient him the first few seconds, but she can’t really capitalize on it in a meaningful way.

Pete wrecks

By that logic she's more durable than DCEU wonder woman and even post crisis WW, she only has better piercing

Peter took being smashed through multiple floors which are definitely thicker than those pillars

OT: Peter stomps, he's superior in every way barring piercing durablity

Spider-Man outclasses her in every way except maybe durability, he should stomp

Spidey destroys 10/10,

can used his spidey sense with eyes closes!

Peter stomps. An argument can be made for her being tougher but he's superior in every other category

Pete stomps here. Decently easy.

Spider-Man ez

Spidey stomps. You need to be at least Butcher to have a good shot for the win.

Peter both rounds low diff.

In R2, She could blind him and it couldn't matter.. He beats her eyes closed.

Starlight kills poor boy

Peter accidentally kills her

Peter murks

Peter solos the verse if he wants to.

@supremesorcerer: stop trolling bro

Spider-Man stomps

In character, Peter may take some damage but he stomps nevertheless.

Lockable lol

Mismatch, Peter outstats her in every possible way

Either can win and Starlight is getting lowballed here. She is way more durable, has better healing, strikes harder in combat by making Stormfront bleed and punched a safe door similar to the feat of Bushmaster. She can fly and also trailed A- train in combat…

She has only better piercing durability but that's all. Spiderman survived pumpkin bombs and getting rammed by a train and getting smashed through several floors

Strikes harder? What? Her punches barely makes holes in concrete at all. I don't recall her breaking a door with her physical rather strength but rather than her powers

I'm not even entering into the laughable lifting strength difference. Or Peter's clearly superior speed, and etc. Spidey stomps

Facts.

Peter stomps. She literally has nothing going for her

Unless stated otherwise, piercing and blunt force durability directly scale. Piercing is just force focused on a small area, like cutting. A punch is that but a larger area.

Both of those feats injured him severely, with one killing him. He isn’t comparable to her in this fight in that department.

His best bet is to use his assets against her. Speed and agility