How do I feel about other writers writing Superior differently than I do?
Honest answer: Great!
Batman reads differently in BATMAN than he does in DETECTIVE, than he does in BATMAN & ROBIN, than he does in JUSTICE LEAGUE, than he does in EARTH 2, than he does in DARK KNIGHT, than he does in-- Well, you get the idea.
Spider-Man reading differently in different Marvel titles (SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN, SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN TEAM-UP, AVENGERS, MIGHTY AVENGERS, A+X, DAREDEVIL, DEADPOOL, JOURNEY INTO MYSTERY, CARNAGE, AGE OF ULTRON, etc...) is going to happen for one simple reason...
...writers are different people. They have different voices that they are going to bring to the table with whatever character they're working on. And that's great! One person might like the way Rick Remender writes Captain America in the solo book, another might prefer the way Jonathan Hickman writes him over in AVENGERS, some might prefer him more in AVENGERS ASSEMBLE or SECRET AVENGERS or what-have-you. That's a good thing because it gives readers more choices.
There shouldn't be a cookie-cutter way of writing any major iconic character. Because everyone's going to have a different take. I remember, as a kid, being excited to see the radically different way Batman was being written and drawn when he showed up in a SWAMP THING comic. He wasn't looking or acting at all like the Batman I was used to in my favorite DC book at the time, BRAVE & THE BOLD. That was the first time I noticed that as a young reader. And it didn't get me bent out of shape. It did just the opposite... It made me realize that there was more than one side to this character-- and I wanted to pick up more books that could show me that.
I love the way Yost writes Superior when he uses him in SSMTU or SCARLET SPIDER. It's not exactly what I would do-- which is what makes it cool to me. But at its heart, he's still the same basic character at his core, we touch on each other's continuity, and it all fits together. In my eyes, that makes these characters more human too. You don't act the same way with your parents that you do with your friends, or co-workers, or the person at the check out, or your nephew, or your business partner, or your date, or your elderly neighbor, and so on... So why should characters act EXACTLY the way they do from title to title?
Log in to comment